Gatsby Shoes Reviews 2023 | Is Gatsby Really FAKE or NOT?


Men in the United States like to wear matching shoes to their attire. Gatsby is a great option for their simplicity and smart look. With mixed reviews surfacing on the internet, we’ve decided to delve deeper and offer you an unbiased review.


If you are interested in shopping from Gatsby, read this detailed Gatsby shoes reviews to find out if it is safe, if customers had good or bad experiences shopping with it, and what to expect. This guide provides a brief explanation of how the store works.

I will dive deeper into their shoes to review their product quality, design and aesthetics, comfort, durability, and customer service.

In this Gatsby shoe review, We’ll also talk about their performance and other important factors like return policy and privacy policy. Join us to know if it is a good idea to buy from Gatsby shoes.

Table of Contents

What is Gatsby Shoes?

Gatsby Shoes, an online footwear retailer, has become a topic of discussion in the shoe community. Gatsby Shoes are a line of dress shoes designed for individuals who prefer smart, stylish shoes that are comfortable and not too formal for everyday occasions.

These shoes are available in various styles, including casual shoes, driving moccasins, slip-on shoes, classic loafers, and business.

Where Are Gatsby Shoes Manufactured?

The exact place where Gatsby shoes are made is a bit tricky to pin down. While the company’s offices are in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, and Carroll, Ohio, in the USA, the actual factories where they create the shoes seem to be a bit of a mystery.

Some folks say Gatsby Shoes are manufactured in China, while others claim they’re handcrafted in Italy. Gatsby may source its shoes from different factories in different countries. So, it’s like a puzzle with pieces from all over the world!

Design and Aesthetics

From a design perspective, Gatsby Shoes have been praised for their “simple and smart” look. For instance, the London Brogues Gatsby Burgundy was described as “divine and beautifully made.” These shoes’ appeal seems to lie in their aesthetic versatility, able to complement both formal and casual ensembles.

Quality and Comfort

Concerns arise when we shift our focus from design to quality. Many customers have reported that the shoes are “fake and plastic,” with inaccurate sizing and poor overall quality. Some buyers even suggested insoles for added comfort, indicating that the shoes might lack sufficient cushioning.

Gatsby Mens Shoes Reviews


While doing gatsby shoe review I noticed that Gatsby Men’s Shoes offer a sophisticated, classic look with an exterior leather finish reminiscent of the roaring ’20s. 

However, the shoes are a mixed bag for comfort and support. It has sizing issues and huge quality issues. It might not provide long-term durability as the building materials could be better.

Pros and Cons of Gatsby Shoes

Gatsby shoes offer a stylish design and orthopedic benefits at an affordable price. However, some customers have raised concerns about fit, material quality, delivery delays, and customer service.

Here are the pros and cons of Gatsby shoes:


  1. Stylish Design: They have a simple, smart look that appeals to many customers.
  2. Variety: Offering a wide selection of men’s shoes, including orthopedic dress shoes.
  3. Orthopedic Benefits: Their orthopedic dress shoes are recommended by doctors for improving foot health and providing daily comfort.
  4. Affordable Pricing: Manufactured in China, which allows for competitive pricing.


  1. Fit: Some users have reported that the shoes feel narrow.
  2. Material Quality: There are concerns about the materials’ quality due to their affordable pricing.
  3. Delivery: Customers have reported delivery delays, possibly due to international shipping.
  4. Customer Service: Complaints registered with the Better Business Bureau highlight potential customer service or product quality issues.

Gatsby Shoe Company Reviews

Gatsby Shoes did not provide any data that could prove its legitimacy. They are hiding their physical address from the buyers. I also could not find any owner information. There is no contact address which raises suspicion. 

Several customers have accused the company of being a scam, citing issues such as receiving the wrong size and inadequate customer service response. Despite these negative reviews, the company has managed to maintain a 3.8-star rating on Trustpilot and a 3.5-star rating on Marifilmines.

Is Gatsby shoes Legit or Fake?


While the aesthetic appeal of Gatsby Shoes is undeniable, the numerous concerns regarding quality, sizing, and customer service must be addressed. It missed showcasing relevant data to prove its legitimacy. They are also hiding their physical address and owner information.

Gatsby Shoes is a footwear brand that has stirred mixed reactions among customers. 

On Trustpilot, Gatsbyshoes has a 3.8-star rating based on feedback from 878 people. But, the Better Business Bureau paints a different picture with some negative reviews stating that Gatsby Shoes are not good products or companies, that the shoes are fake and plastic, and the sizes are inaccurate. So, they are likely to be scammers.

Gatsby Shoes Website Review

I have looked into gatsbyshoes. co in whois. I have provided the whois record for gatsbyshoes. co below to give you some information about their website:

Domain Profile

Registrar: GoDaddy LLC

IANA ID: 146

Registrar Status

clientDeleteProhibited, clientRenewProhibited, clientTransferProhibited, clientUpdateProhibited


1,066 days old

Created on 2020-08-21

Expires on 2023-08-21

Updated on 2022-08-27

IP Address – 3,640,435 other sites hosted on this server

IP Location

 – Ontario – Ottawa – Shopify Inc.

Risk Check

Is Gatsby shoes legit? We better take a closer look at this website and its Shoe industry. 


  • Domain Creation Date: Friday 21st, August 2020, 12:00 am
  • Website Popularity: 436610 (Medium)
  • Domain Blacklist Status: Not detected by any blacklist engine
  • HTTPS Connection: Valid HTTPS Found
  • Proximity to Suspicious Websites: 15/100
  • Threat Profile: 4/100
  • Phishing Score: 4/100
  • Malware Score: 2/100
  • Spam Score: 0/100

The Scam Detector’s website validator has given gatsbyshoes. co an authoritative rank of 29.00, which classifies the platform as potentially risky, dubious, and dangerous. The score is based on various factors, including the newness of the domain, which can impact the site’s trustworthiness. 

The algorithm considers 52 relevant factors in the website’s Shoe niche, such as Tranco rank, the location of the IP address, the technology used, and customer service quality.

The website is also assessed for proximity to suspicious websites and assigned scores for threat, phishing, malware, and spam profiles. Scores below 30 are relatively less dangerous, while anything above that may raise concerns as potential red flags.

Domain Authority Check

The domain authority of the site is quite low.

URLPage AuthorityDomain AuthorityLinking Root DomainsTotal Links
www.getsbyshoes. com19.0022.0000

Customer Service

Customer service appears to be an area of contention for Gatsby Shoes. Several customers have reported issues with receiving the wrong size and a lack of satisfactory resolution from the company. The business practices of this company have been questioned, and some customers have labeled it as a potential scam.

Gatsby Shoes Reviews From Real Customer

It has a 1.6 rating on the product review website. Several customers complained about receiving incorrect sizes, poor quality products, and being denied refunds or replacements. The company’s customer service is described as unhelpful and unresponsive, and there are allegations of it being a scam company. Some customers also reported misleading product descriptions and difficulty unsubscribing from marketing messages. 

On Trustpilot, Gatsby Shoes has received mixed reviews from customers. Some customers expressed frustration with the company’s response time and communication; some even considered the company a scam. Due to these issues and the company’s poor reputation, potential buyers are advised to refrain from purchasing from Gatsby Shoes.

Return and Refund Policy

Gatsby has a return policy. Customers also can get refunds, and they can exchange products too. But it is only available within 30 days after purchasing.

Their refund policy is misleading and deceptive. They utilized the statement “full refund,” but the refund was not given to customers. Their owner Gabriel Miller could not address the issue.

Delivery and Shipping Policy

It will normally take 10 to 30 business days for the product purchased on this site to be shipped and delivered. You can also visit their website to understand about shipping policy in detail.

Gatsby Shoe Review

After reading all the details on Gatsby shoes review you might be still wondering if Gatsby shoes legit or fake!

In this Review you will see he got a fresh pair of Gatsby shoes and reviewed it.

List Of More Scam Shoe Brands

In recent times, various shoe brands, including Gatsby Shoes, have left buyers deceived and frustrated through a range of scams. Some individuals experience delayed deliveries, while others have yet to receive their shoes or struggle to secure refunds.

It is essential to shed light on these specific brands and their deceptive tactics.

  • Owlkay Shoes, for instance, have gained notoriety for their delayed deliveries. If you possess extraordinary patience, consider ordering from them, although the waiting period can be substantial.
  • Moving on to Arkget Shoes, I found that they did not care about delivering quality products. My Arkget Shoes review provides an in-depth analysis of the quality of their products.
  • The Dotmalls Shoes are in the same category as Arkget Shoes, which do not meet buyer expectations. A common thread among their customers is disappointment. Dotmalls Shoes review provides more information about the Dotmalls scam
  • Another brand embroiled in controversy is Softsfeel shoes, seen as a scam. Many dissatisfied customers are vocalizing their grievances on Trustpilot about these shoes.

In the face of these scams, exercising vigilance is crucial. Before making any shoe-related purchases, it’s imperative to research thoroughly.

This way, you can ensure that you don’t fall victim to these deceitful practices.


Gatsby shoes are known for their simple and smart design, offering various styles, including orthopedic dress shoes. However, concerns have arisen regarding the shoes’ quality, sizing, and durability. Some customers have reported that the shoes are fake and plastic, with inaccurate sizing and poor overall quality. 

Their shoes are so narrow that it causes discomfort. Some buyers have even suggested purchasing insoles for added comfort.

There are some concerns on their website too. It has very low domain and page authority. They need owner information and physical address on their site. Therefore, potential buyers should consider these mixed reviews before purchasing, and Gatsby shoes is most likely a scam.

Thanks for reading this Gatsby shoe review, don’t forget to let us know your opinion or experiences about their shoe in our comment box.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Gatsby shoes made in China?

Yes, Gatsby’s shoes are made in China.

Who is the owner of Gatsby shoes?

Gatsby Shoes is owned by Gabriel Miller, who reportedly generated 2.4 million dollars in revenue in 2021.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *